Posted December 19, 2020
Senate Disciplinary Appeal Committee
Disciplinary Appeal
Case Number: [Office Use Only]
Florida Legislature
Officer Presiding: [Office Use Only]
NAME
Diego Guerra
and
GOV. DEPARTMENT
Florida Highway Patrol
**DISCLAIMER: IF POSSIBLE, YOU MUST FIRST APPEAL INTERNALLY WITHIN YOUR DEPARTMENT
YOU MUST BE LISTED AS ACTIVE ON THE FLORIDA STATE POLICE ROSTER PRIOR TO DISCIPLINE (10 Hours a Week) TO PLACE A SENATE APPEAL**
Information
Trooper's Name: Diego Guerra
Organization: Florida Highway Patrol
Rank: Senior Trooper
Department: Highway Patrol
Badge Number (If Applicable): 231
Punishment you were given: 2 Warnings and Removal of Firearms Training
Grounds for Appeal (Why should it be overturned): Officers face day to day life endangering split second decisions. In this case as the suspect show utter lack of care for anyone else but himself I can safely say I feel the use of force might have been relatively addecuate as there was a realistic and continuous fear for my life. According to Graham vs Connor when deciding if any punishment is required after an alleged use of force violation a lot of factors must be taken into account and in this specific case not just the fact the suspect ended up not having a weapon. I always respect use of force policies and have never been issued any sort of punishment regarding this or any other SOP violations. I feel the punishment was excessive and bigger factors other than "must follow SOP's to the lettter" were disregarded. I must add the only reason I fired my weapon is because in the motion of him putting up his fists to attack me I (in a split second decision) saw what looked like a weapon drawing motion from his waist. After firing one single shot I had enough time to process he didn't have a weapon and made the decision to stop shooting.
Any evidence to support this:
Have you requested reasons for your discipline (if yes, please paste them as a reply to this appeal): Class Z
Do you know the case against you (have you seen the evidence)?: No evidence/On the spot punishment
Do you request the Florida Senate Disciplinary Appeal Committee obtain all evidence help by the government in relation to your case?: Yes
Please link your original appeal which must have been denied here: